Many of us can’t proceed throughout the day without getting a nice cup of coffee in the morning. Fortunately, you don’t have to empty your bank account just for a good coffee maker. MR Coffee Optimal vs Black And Decker are basic coffee makers that are quite budget-friendly. Below, we will help you choose between the two models.
Read on below if you want to find out further about:
• The design and dimensions of each coffee maker
• The water reservoir capacity of each model
• The features and operation of each model
• The brew quality of MR Coffee Optimal vs Black And Decker
• A few other things to consider when choosing a coffee maker
• Whether MR Coffee Optimal or Black And Decker is better
Design and Dimensions
First of all, we are going to compare the designs and dimensions of the two coffee makers. In terms of appearance, both models look nice. MR Coffee Optimal is slightly better here because of the rectangular shape and firm lines, which give the unit a modern and professional vibe. On the other hand, Black And Decker actually doesn’t look bad, but it also looks a bit like a blender or juicer. See also: Breville Duo Temp Pro vs Gaggia Classic.
MR Coffee Optimal 10-Cup BVMC-PSTX91-RB comes with two color choices, black/chrome and chrome. Actually, the difference between the two variants isn’t much. The black/chrome version simply has a black part on the front while the rest of the surface is chrome, whereas the chrome version’s front side is all chrome.
On the top right corner, there is a small display that shows the clock and the brew timer. There are also a few buttons for adjusting the brew timer and accessing some functions, such as clean, delay brew, and brew now. MR Coffee Optimal is a relatively bulky coffee maker, as it measures 14.12 inches x 11 inches x 9 inches.
Black And Decker 12-Cup CM1160B, on the other hand, is available in three color choices: black, black/stainless steel, and white/stainless steel. So, you get more options. The black version is entirely black, while the black/stainless steel version features a stainless steel liner on the top and a different set of buttons. The white/stainless steel version is similar to the black/stainless steel version except for the white color.
The control buttons of Black And Decker are placed in front of the carafe plate. While they are easy to access, they may get accidentally bumped and pressed when you are putting or taking the carafe. Black And Decker is a relatively smaller coffee machine, as it measures 12.25 inches x 11 inches x 8.25 inches.
The next difference between MR Coffee Optimal vs Black And Decker is the capacity. If you want to buy a new coffee maker, you should consider the capacity of the water reservoir. If it is too small and the coffee maker is going to be used by lots of people, you will need to refill the water reservoir way too frequently. In general, having a larger water reservoir is almost always better.
MR Coffee Optimal BVMC-PSTX91-RB is a 10-cup coffee maker. This model has a removable water reservoir to allow easy refill. One nice thing about this coffee maker is that the water reservoir is easy to remove, and you can put it back without any difficulty. However, the 10-cup capacity is not much. It is great for personal use and perhaps for a small group of people, but it will need to be refilled frequently if there are many coffee drinkers.
Black And Decker CM1160B is a 12-cup coffee maker. So, this coffee maker has a slightly larger water reservoir. Unfortunately, the water reservoir is a bit difficult to access, even though it is indeed removable. Nevertheless, the slightly larger capacity means that it will involve less frequent refill, so it still can offer some degree of convenience, especially if the coffee maker is used by multiple people.
Now, we will compare the operation of MR Coffee Optimal vs Black And Decker. There are several things that both coffee machines have in common, such as the clock and the brew timer functions. However, there are also a few distinctive capabilities that set the two apart.
Both models here have a timer function. You can program either coffee maker so that it will brew your coffee automatically at a certain time everyday. This way, you can have fresh and warm coffee every morning when you wake up. MR Coffee Optimal additionally has the “Freshness Timer” feature which will help you keep track the freshness of the coffee inside the carafe.
Both models also allow you to brew new coffee outside the programmed time. Both models have a feature that will allow you to pause the brewing temporarily so that you can pour a cup of coffee right away without waiting for the carafe to be completely filled – a very useful feature when you are in a hurry.
Unfortunately, MR Coffee Optimal does not have an automatic shut-off feature, so you should not forget to turn it off after brewing your coffee. It also lacks a warmer to keep the coffee warm for a long time, although the stainless steel carafe works well in keeping the freshness for an hour or two.
The carafe of MR Coffee Optimal is completely stainless steel, without any window for you to see the amount of remaining coffee inside. You need to open the lid to see the remaining coffee.
On the other hand, Black And Decker has a 2-hour auto shut-off, so you don’t need to worry about forgetting to turn off the coffee maker after usage. This will give you some peace of mind. It also has a nonstick carafe plate that is said to be able to keep the coffee hot for about an hour since the brewing time.
Without the warming plate, the glass carafe of Black And Decker doesn’t really keep the coffee hot for a long time. However, the glass carafe is quite durable, and the transparent wall will allow you to see the amount of remaining coffee easily.
It is not a secret that cheap coffee makers like MR Coffee Optimal vs Black And Decker don’t make the greatest brew in the world. However, you probably don’t really mind about the brew quality as long as it is still tolerable and drinkable for your morning coffee. Well, MR Coffee Optimal and Black And Decker are just okay in terms of brew quality.
MR Coffee Optimal claims to be able to brew 20% faster than competitive units in its class. However, this isn’t really significant in real use, as it is not really faster than Black And Decker in comparison.
The brew quality of MR Coffee Optimal is pretty good. The company claims that this model brews at a temperature of 205 degrees to deliver rich, flavorful coffee. The produced coffee is indeed hot, and the coffee taste is noticeable. However, the flavor is not really as strong as expected.
Black And Decker tends to take 3 – 4 minutes to complete a brewing cycle. It will feel slow if you are waiting for the coffee maker to finish brewing without anything else to do, so programming the auto brew function for your morning coffee is highly recommended.
The brew quality of Black And Decker is also pretty good. It can deliver hot coffee with a recognizable flavor. However, just like MR Coffee Optimal, Black And Decker does not really deliver strong coffee. The brew is rather mild.
Last but not least, there are also a few other things that you need to consider when choosing between these two coffee makers. A coffee maker usually requires a filter, and many models require you to replace the filter frequently. Also, just like buying any other appliance, you need to check the warranty.
MR Coffee Optimal BVMC-PSTX91-RB is really interesting because it comes with the Gold Tone permanent filter. This high-quality filter can remove 97% of chlorine from the water. The filter can last for a lifetime, hence eliminating the cost of replacements. It is a very good choice if you don’t want to spend money over filter replacements in the future.
MR Coffee Optimal is backed by a 1-year limited warranty. Make sure to check the quality of the parts after the purchase. If you find a defect, you can make a warranty claim to get a replacement.
Black And Decker CM1160B does not come with a permanent filter, so it will require constant filter replacements. This is not a big problem because paper filters are quite cheap and easy to find. Still, if you don’t want to spend more money in the future, this is something to consider. Black And Decker is backed by a 2-year limited warranty.
MR Coffee Optimal vs Black And Decker
In general, MR Coffee Optimal is more recommended. It is generally easier to use. The stainless steel carafe is nice. In addition, it has a permanent filter which will eliminate filter replacement cost.