Cuisinart DCC-3200 vs Bonavita BV1901PW

Indeed, both Cuisinart DCC-3200 vs Bonavita BV1901PW are excellent coffee makers that are very easy and practical to use. However, these two models have very different features and capabilities. Depending on what you need from your coffee maker, you will find either Cuisinart DCC-3200 or Bonavita BV1901PW to be more useful than the other. So, which one should you choose?

Read the discussion below to learn further about:
– The design and build quality of each coffee maker here
– How each coffee maker here is operated
– Which model that has a larger capacity
– The features of Cuisinart DCC-3200 vs Bonavita BV1901PW
– The comparison of their performance and coffee quality
– Which coffee maker that is generally more recommended

Cuisinart DCC-3200: Design and Build Quality
Cuisinart DCC-3200 is a 14-cup programmable coffee maker (take a look at our previous post about Cuisinart DCC-3200 vs Braun Brewsense here). It is really cool because, in addition to the excellent ease of use, it offers a wide range of customization which enables you to adjust the brewing process for the perfect coffee according to your taste. Hence, this coffee maker is suitable for coffee lovers with specific preferences in regards to their coffee.

The control panel has several buttons, which may make it appear daunting in the eyes of a beginner. On the good side, the operation is actually quite straightforward once you get the hang of it. The control panel also features a blue backlit display which is very easy to read and will allow you to brew a cup of coffee easily at night.

Compared to Bonavita BV1901PW, Cuisinart DCC-3200 is indeed larger and heavier. It will eat up some space. Though, to be fair, this coffee maker is not overly bulky. It can still fit easily into a medium-sized kitchen, but it may be a bit too large if you are living in a studio apartment.

The overall build quality is pretty good. The housing is made of metal and plastic. All plastic parts are BPA-free. It comes with a solid glass carafe that features black accents and a stainless steel handle that won’t get hot. Cuisinart DCC-3200 is quite easy to clean; the lid, carafe, and brew basket can be washed on the top rack of a dishwasher, whereas the internal parts can be purged by running a mixture of vinegar and water.

Cuisinart DCC-3200: Features
The most defining difference that sets Cuisinart DCC-3200 vs Bonavita BV1901PW apart is their feature sets. Cuisinart DCC-3200 comes with a multitude of options and is programmable, whereas Bonavita BV1901PW emphasizes on utter ease of use and simplicity.

Cuisinart DCC-3200 comes with a gold-tone permanent filter, but you can still use disposable paper filters if you want. This coffee maker will let you choose the brew strength, either regular or bold. On the control panel, you can increase or decrease the temperature of the warming plate to suit your liking.

The programmability will allow you to set Cuisinart DCC-3200 up to 24 hours ahead to start brewing automatically at the specified time. This is very useful for preparing coffee for every tomorrow morning. Nevertheless, you can press the 1-4 Cup button in order to get just one or a few cups of coffee instead of a full pot.

Cuisinart DCC-3200 has the auto shut-off feature, so you won’t need to worry when you forget to turn off the coffee machine. The box includes a chlorine filter, which you can use to remove impurities from your tap water. The warranty is valid for one year since the purchase date.

Cuisinart DCC-3200: Performance
So, how is the performance of Cuisinart DCC-3200 vs Bonavita BW1901PW? Although Cuisinart DCC-3200 has various nice features, the coffee quality is not as impressive. It is unable to brew coffee with rich flavor; though, people who just want quick coffee in the morning probably won’t complain.

The unit takes 5 – 10 minutes to brew a full pot of coffee. There is a brew pause function which will allow you to sneak a cup during the brewing process, but remember to be quick as the pause is only for 20 seconds.

The coffee quality of Cuisinart DCC-3200 is underwhelming. The regular brew strength setting produces coffee that is weak and watery. Meanwhile, the bold brew strength setting helps to improve the flavor, but it is still not as rich and strong as desired. Though, on the good side, the coffee is without excessive bitterness.

Not all hope is lost. Casual coffee drinkers may find the bold setting sufficient, but if you are an avid coffee lover, you can try adding extra grounds into the filter basket in order to increase the coffee flavor. That said, do not use more than 15 tablespoons of grounds, as it may cause the coffee to overflow during the brewing.

Bonavita BV1901PW: Design and Build Quality
Bonavita BV1901PW may remind you of its siblings, Bonavita BV1800 and Bonavita BV1900. It sports a similar retro look, with a streamlined and minimalist design. The two things that become the defining features of Bonavita BV1901PW are the floating filter basket and the beautiful black finish.

This coffee maker is very compact and lightweight. It is an excellent choice if space availability is an issue.

On the top, you can find a circular lid which will reveal the water reservoir when opened. Beside it, there is the brewer lid which covers the showerhead. The operation of Bonavita BV1901PW is extremely simple. Simply add the amount of water that you want and put the ground coffee inside the filter basket, then press the power button. It will start brewing coffee immediately. No fuss, no confusing settings.

The overall build quality is excellent. The housing is made of BPA-free plastic, and is solid and durable. Bonavita BV1901PW comes with a glass carafe, which is also well-made with an 8-cup capacity. Note that the box includes a lid for the carafe, which you definitely want to use once the brewing process is completed in order to keep the heat inside.

This coffee maker is backed by a 2-year warranty, which will cover any manufacturing defect in the product. However, it doesn’t cover damage from improper use, neglect, or abuse.

Bonavita BV1901PW: Features
The most highlighted feature of Bonavita BV1901PW is the “One-Touch Operation” – which refers to the simple button operation. You can brew quality coffee with just a push of a button. As a note, the coffee quality is indeed very good, as you’ll see below. The obvious downside is that there is no customization, so you won’t be able to tinker with the brewing process.

Bonavita BV1901PW comes with a large showerhead and a flat-bottom filter basket. According to the manufacturer, these two features are essential to allow even saturation and optimum extraction of the coffee.

The coffee maker is armed with a 1560-Watt heating element, which enables the unit to reach the ideal brewing temperature (198 – 205 degrees Fahrenheit) very quickly and keep the stability. This is another reason why the coffee quality can be very good, in addition to the large showerhead and flat-bottom filter basket.

Finally, Bonavita BV1901PW comes with the optional Pre-Infusion Mode. This mode can be activated by pressing the power button for five seconds. This mode will cause the ground coffee to be soaked for a while before the actual brewing process. It allows the ground coffee to degas, and helps the coffee maker to produce stronger and more intense flavor.

Bonavita BV1901PW: Performance and Coffee Quality
Bonavita BV1901PW performs impressively. The brewing process is fairly fast; it is able to brew a full pot of coffee (for 8 cups) within 8 minutes. Although it is slightly slower than Cuisinart DCC-3200, Bonavita BV1901PW still has the better edge because of its great coffee quality.

The company claims that Bonavita BV1901PW is able to maintain a stable temperature within the optimal brewing temperature range. When tested with a thermometer, this is indeed true. The coffee maker only takes 2 minutes to reach 200 degrees Fahrenheit, and it remains between 200 and 201 degrees Fahrenheit until the end of the brewing cycle.

The performance of Bonavita BV1901PW is similar to its sibling, Bonavita BV1900, which is an SCAA-certified coffee maker. Apparently, this model is not certified because of the carafe, which is not able to keep the coffee hot for long enough. Still, the coffee flavor is really great.

The coffee flavor is smooth and rich. It does not have any bitterness, meaning that the brewing process is performed properly without burning the coffee. You will enjoy the rich coffee flavor with all of its complexity. For sure, Bonavita BV1901PW is one of the very few coffee makers that are actually able to deliver quality coffee.

Cuisinart DCC-3200 vs Bonavita BV1901PW

- State-of-the-art technology to ensure hotter coffee without sacrificing flavor or quality
- Brew strength control allows you to select regular or bold coffee flavor
- Fully automatic with 24-hour programmability, self-clean, 1-4 cup setting and auto shutoff (0-4 hours)
- Powerful 1560-watt heater with advanced heating control quickly brings water to ideal brewing temperature of 198° to 205°F (92°- 96°C)
- Removable flat bottom filter basket and larger showerhead provide better saturation and uniform flavor extraction
- Audible signal alerts user when the filter basket has finished draining and coffee is ready

In general, Bonavita BV1901PW is more recommended because of its excellent performance and coffee quality. It consistently brews in the ideal brewing temperature range and delivers rich coffee flavor. It is also suitable for people with limited space, as it has a compact body. The one-touch operation is very simple and straightforward.

Leave a Comment