Bonavita BV1800SS vs BV1900TS

Bonavita BV1800SS vs BV1900TS are 8-cup coffee brewers that have been certified by the SCAA, which means that their coffee quality is excellent. But there are notable differences in specs and features. So, which one is better? Read the comparison between these two coffee makers below to find out.

The discussion below will tell you further about:
– The design and build quality of each coffee maker
– The filter basket design on each model
– The features of Bonavita BV1800SS vs BV1900TS
– The comparison of their performance and coffee quality
– Which coffee maker that is generally better

Bonavita BV1800SS: Design and Build Quality
Bonavita BV1800SS comes with a similar minimalist retro design like the original 1800 model, with just a few small adjustments. The most noticeable change is on the carafe. Instead of a curvy glass carafe with a flared lip, Bonavita BV1800SS comes with a solid stainless steel carafe that is accented with black plastic. This new carafe design is actually more similar to the other models in the line-up, such as Bonavita BV1900TS vs BV1500TS.

In order to accommodate the increased dimensions of the dual-walled carafe, Bonavita BV1800SS has reduced drastically the thickness of the carafe platform. This also helps to make the unit appear sleek. The carafe can hold enough coffee for up to 8 cups.

The water reservoir is nice. In addition to the existing cup measurements, there are also markings for measuring water volume in mL. Finally, Bonavita BV1800SS comes with an opaque filter basket that matches the overall color scheme of the unit. All parts are BPA-free.

Compared to Bonavita BV1900TS, Bonavita BV1800SS is slightly more compact. It measures 10.75 inches long, 6.25 inches wide, and 12.25 inches tall.

Overall, Bonavita BV1800SS is a solid coffee brewer. The build quality is excellent. The carafe, in particular, is really solid and durable. The only weakness is the flimsy lid hinges, but this won’t affect the usability or coffee quality. Bonavita BV1800SS is backed by a 2-year limited warranty.

Bonavita BV1800SS: Features
As mentioned above, one of the main differences between Bonavita BV1800SS vs BV1900TS is the features. More specifically, you will find a difference in the power of the heating element.

Bonavita BV1800SS is armed with a 1400-Watt heating element. It is said to be able to provide consistent brewing temperatures between 195 – 205 degrees Fahrenheit. Of course, this is the ideal brewing temperature range, and this is one of the reasons why Bonavita BV1800SS has managed to achieve the SCAA certification. However, compared to Bonavita BV1900TS, the heating element of Bonavita BV1800SS is slightly less powerful, so it will take a bit longer to brew your coffee.

The Bonavita BV1800SS coffee brewer also comes with a feature called “One-Touch Brew”. In order to brew your coffee, you only need to add the ground coffee into the filter basket, add water into the reservoir, and push a single button. That’s all – the machine will start brewing immediately and give you quality coffee within a few minutes. It is very simple and straightforward with no room for errors.

Of course, Bonavita BV1800SS lacks customization. You can’t change the brew strength or anything like that. But this is not a problem if you just want a simple coffee brewer that can give you good coffee every morning.

The carafe works very well in keeping your coffee hot for a few hours. This is one nice advantage of glass carafes. In addition, the shape of the carafe has been optimized to prevent spills. It is now practically spill-proof, so you will never waste a drop of precious coffee.

Bonavita BV1800SS: Performance and Coffee Quality
Both Bonavita BV1800SS vs BV1900TS are two of the very few automatic coffee brewers that have been certified by the SCAA. This is an impressive feat, and it definitely helps to make Bonavita BV1800SS and Bonavita BV1900TS stand apart from the competition.

Every SCAA-certified coffee brewer has gone through intensive testing to ensure good brewing quality and consistent performance. According to the users, Bonavita BV1800SS indeed has excellent consistent performance. It always delivers rich coffee flavor, even after months of usage.

The showerhead is wide, and the holes are arranged in a cross pattern to ensure even water flow and adequate saturation of the ground coffee. The filter basket is U-shaped with a flat bottom, which helps to increase the exposure time between the water and the coffee and enables proper extraction.

Bonavita BV1800SS works quietly. Compared to Bonavita BV1900TS, the coffee quality is similarly good. But Bonavita BV1800SS works more slowly; it takes about 10 minutes to brew a full pot for 8 cups.

Bonavita BV1900TS: Design and Build Quality
In terms of design, Bonavita BV1800SS vs BV1900TS may look similar. They both sport a retro look that is simple and minimalist. They both have a stainless steel finish with black accents. If anything, the distinction of Bonavita BV1900TS is the rounded oval shape of the water reservoir.

Bonavita BV1900TS measures 12.40 inches long, 6.80 inches wide, and 12.20 inches tall. On the top, there is a circular lid that covers the water reservoir. Simply open it in order to add water to brew your coffee. Next to it is the brewer lid which conceals the showerhead. All plastic parts in this coffee brewer are BPA-free and safe to use.

The operation is extremely simple. After adding the necessary amount of water and putting the ground coffee into the filter basket, all you need to do is press the power button. Bonavita BV1900TS will start brewing right away to give you quality coffee.

The build quality is excellent. Bonavita BV1900TS comes with a double-walled stainless steel carafe, which is very good in keeping your coffee hot for several hours. The carafe is solid and durable. The capacity is also 8 cups. The main unit itself is built to last.

Bonavita BV1900TS is backed by a 2-year warranty as well. It will cover all manufacturing defects, but it doesn’t cover damage from improper use or abuse.

Bonavita BV1900TS: Features
Just like its sibling that we discussed previously, Bonavita BV1900TS boasts the “One-Touch Operation” – referring to the simple button operation, which makes it a great coffee brewer for busy people who don’t have much time in the morning. Again, there is no customization, but this is not a problem for people who just want to get good coffee quickly.

Bonavita BV1900TS also features a large showerhead and a flat-bottom filter basket. Both of these features are essential for even saturation and extraction of the coffee.

However, what makes Bonavita BV1900TS a better coffee machine is the 1500-Watt heating element. It is able to brew coffee in a more accurate and consistent temperature range between 198 – 205 degrees Fahrenheit. In addition, it heats up more quickly, so it can deliver your coffee within a shorter period of time.

That’s not all. There is another special feature that Bonavita BV1900TS offers, which is the Pre-Infusion Mode. This is an optional mode that you can activate by holding the power button down for five seconds (accessing this mode, while easy, is not immediately obvious – so make sure to read the user manual).

The Pre-Infusion Mode will soak the ground coffee for a while before actually starting brewing. This is to allow the ground coffee to degas. Afterwards, the light indicator will flash to indicate the start of the brewing process. When tested, the Pre-Infusion Mode consistently delivers stronger, more intense coffee flavor.

Bonavita BV1900TS: Performance and Coffee Quality
Bonavita BV1900TS definitely performs like a champion. It is pretty fast, as it can brew a 45-oz pot of coffee within less than 8 minutes. You can get enough coffee for everybody in your house or office room within just several minutes.

When measured with dedicated tools, Bonavita BV1900TS shows impressive capabilities. It can reach 200 degrees Fahrenheit within 2 minutes, and it keeps the temperature between 200 and 201 degrees for the rest of the brewing cycle. As a result, the produced coffee can have excellent full-bodied flavor. No wonder that SCAA has given Bonavita BV1900TS a certification.

According to the more experienced users, the performance of Bonavita BV1900TS is comparable with the renowned Moccamaster, although the latter has the ability to reach 200 degrees Fahrenheit a little bit faster. Nevertheless, Bonavita BV1900TS is already really great, considering that it is aimed for home users.

The best way to describe the coffee flavor is “smooth”. There is little to no bitter taste, which means that the coffee is not burnt during the brewing process. Instead, you will enjoy rich coffee flavor with all of its complexity. No other coffee machines in this price range can deliver such great coffee.

Bonavita BV1800SS vs BV1900TS

- Showerhead designed for complete saturation and optimal extraction
- Durable, stainless steel lined thermal carafe keeps coffee warm
- Carafe lid, filter basket, and showerhead are dishwasher safe and all plastic is BPA-free
- Optional pre-infusion mode wets freshly roasted ground coffee to allow degassing before brewing
- Flat-bottomed filter basket and larger showerhead allow for even better saturation and uniform extraction
- Durable stainless steel lined thermal carafe. Double walled stainless steel thermal carafe


Between these two great coffee makers, Bonavita BV1900TS is more recommended. It has a more powerful heating element, which enables the unit to reach the ideal brewing temperature more quickly and finish the cycle within a shorter time. The performance is impressive. The brewing temperature is very stable, and Bonavita BV1900TS consistently deliver high quality coffee with rich flavor.

Leave a Comment